I want to take the guesswork out of selling your car. I analyze market data, decode DMV title laws, and test out online car buyers to give you a straight answer on whether it's worth holding out for a higher price or if you're better off taking the most convenient offer and moving on.
Published:Apr 3, 2026
Last Updated:Apr 5, 2026
✓ Fact Checked:Apr 3, 2026
How is this page verified?
Information on this article is compiled from publicly available data, customer feedback and our internal analysis. All our articles are being constantly updated and fact-checked annually to ensure accuracy, timeliness, and relevance.
SellCarAdvisor is reader-supported, when you sign up through links on this post, we may receive compensation at no extra cost to you. How We Work.
The bottom line: High oil consumption kills most private sales before they start. The moment you mention it, buyers back out or drop their offer. Online car buyers like Peddle, CashForCars, and Wheelzy work differently. They price mechanical problems into their offers upfront and buy cars as-is.
We submitted 5 oil-burning vehicles to all three to see who offers the most. We also looked at CarBrain, eBay Motors, Facebook Marketplace, and Cars.com as options for sellers who want to try the open market.
The winner changed depending on the vehicle. Getting quotes from 2 to 3 buyers takes about 10 minutes and is the best way to know who offers the most for your specific car.
Our take on Peddle:Peddle buys cars in any condition, including those with engines that burn through oil. Their form asks about the car’s condition and running status, and an oil consumption issue falls squarely within what they handle every day. Quotes are valid for 7 days, so you have time to compare before deciding.
Pros
Gives instant online quotes for oil-burning cars without requiring a phone call
Free towing at pickup even if the engine has gotten worse since you got the quote
Offer stays good for 7 days so you can check other buyers first
Cons
Offer may drop at pickup if the oil issue has caused engine damage you didn’t fully describe
Pickup is a 4-hour window, not a specific time
Won’t buy if you still owe money on the car
Why we picked it: Peddle offered the most on 3 of the 5 oil-burning cars in our test, with the biggest gap on the 2004 Nissan 350Z. Their offer was more than $1,500 higher than the next best instant quote on that car. On the Yaris and Pontiac Vibe, Peddle also came out on top while Wheelzy required a phone call instead of showing an instant quote.
What Peddle says about cars with high oil consumption:
Peddle gives instant online quotes for oil-burning cars and picks them up for free.
Our take on CashForCars:CashForCars is owned by Copart, which runs one of the largest used vehicle auction networks in the country with around 200 locations. That means oil-burning cars that have parts value or auction appeal can sometimes fetch better offers here than from smaller buyers. Their form accepts mechanical problems without requiring a call, and their website specifically says they buy cars with mechanical issues.
Pros
Gave instant quotes on all 5 oil-burning vehicles in our test without routing any to a phone call
Copart’s auction network means more buyers competing for oil-burning cars with resale or parts value
Free towing and same-day pickup available near their 200 locations
Cons
Payment is by check, and your bank may hold it for up to 24 hours before you can access the funds
Offer may change at pickup if the oil issue has caused damage that wasn’t disclosed upfront
Won’t buy if you still owe money on the vehicle
Why we picked it: CashForCars offers on the 350Z ($1,267) and Yaris ($506) were second only to Peddle.
What CashForCars says about cars with mechanical problems:
CashForCars gives instant online quotes for cars with mechanical issues, backed by the Copart auction network.
Our take on Wheelzy:Wheelzy focuses on damaged and non-running vehicles, which makes them a natural fit for oil-burning cars that may be approaching the end of their driving life. Same-day pickup is available in many areas, and their process takes about 2 minutes to get a quote. Their website also specifically mentions buying cars with broken engines and engine damage.
Pros
Specializes in vehicles with engine damage, which includes severe oil consumption cases
Same-day pickup available in many areas if you want the car gone quickly
Free towing even if the oil issue has caused the engine to seize completely
Cons
Required a phone call for 2 out of 5 oil-burning vehicles instead of showing an instant online quote
Offer may drop at pickup if the oil issue has caused damage beyond what was described
Why we picked it: Wheelzy offered more than both Peddle and CashForCars on the 2005 Ford Mustang and 2008 Ford Edge.
However, the 2008 Toyota Yaris and 2009 Pontiac Vibe were routed to a phone call, so expect a mix of instant and non-instant results depending on your vehicle.
What Wheelzy says about buying cars with engine damage (selected in form for oil-burning cars):
Wheelzy picks up oil-burning cars fast, often the same day you accept their offer.
Our take on CarBrain:CarBrain has been buying problem cars since 2007 and has handled close to a million vehicles. Unlike Peddle, Wheelzy, and CashForCars, they let you counter their first offer if you think your oil-burning car is worth more. A car that still drives despite burning oil has more value than a dead one, and being able to push back on the first number can matter when the gap between buyers is wide.
Pros
Lets you counter their first offer, which can help when selling a car that still runs despite burning oil
Buys cars with major engine problems, including high oil consumption that has progressed to engine damage
Free towing and payment before the tow truck leaves with your car
Cons
Won’t buy if the engine or transmission is missing, even if oil consumption is the stated reason
Offers tend to run lower than competitors before negotiating, so always compare first
Title must be in your name before they can proceed with the purchase
Why we picked it: CarBrain wasn’t included in our quote test, but their counteroffer feature makes them worth checking alongside the others. If Peddle offers $500 and CarBrain starts at $400, you can show them the Peddle quote and ask them to move up. That kind of negotiating power doesn’t exist with the other three instant buyers on this list.
CarBrain lets you counter their first offer, which no other instant buyer on this list allows.
Best For Nationwide Enthusiast Buyers: eBay Motors
Our take on eBay Motors:eBay Motors gives you access to around 11 million monthly car shoppers, including hobbyists and mechanics who actively look for project cars or vehicles with known issues they can fix themselves. A car with high oil consumption listed honestly can attract buyers who know the fix and just want the vehicle at the right price.
The listing fee is $19 to $79 with no percentage taken from your sale. You handle the sale yourself, including photos, messaging buyers, and arranging pickup or shipping. Cars that are priced honestly with full disclosure tend to sell faster than those where the issue is buried in fine print.
Best For Free Local Listings: Facebook Marketplace
Our take on Facebook Marketplace:Facebook Marketplace is completely free to list on and reaches local buyers in your area. For a car with high oil consumption, this means you can find a local mechanic, hobbyist, or budget buyer who already knows how to deal with the issue. Listing takes about 15 minutes and your ad goes live immediately with no fees taken from your sale.
The downside is that you manage everything yourself. You’ll need to be upfront about the oil issue in your listing to avoid wasting time with buyers who expect a problem-free car.
Our take on Cars.com:Cars.com is a free listing alternative to eBay Motors and Facebook Marketplace. You put your car in front of about 25 million monthly visitors at no cost and with no time limit on your listing. If eBay’s listing fee or Facebook’s local-only reach doesn’t work for you, Cars.com is worth adding to the mix.
The key with any listing platform for an oil-burning car is being upfront in the description. Mention how often you add oil, whether it smokes, and the car’s overall running condition.
Buyers who find out at inspection tend to walk away. Buyers who know going in are more likely to follow through at the price you set.
Sell a Car with High Oil Consumption: Feature Comparison
Company
How It Works
Quote Speed
Towing
Negotiate?
Instant buyer
Instant online
Free
No
Instant buyer (Copart)
Instant online
Free
No
Instant buyer
Instant or call
Free
Sometimes
Instant buyer
Instant online
Free
Yes
Listing platform
You set price
You arrange
Yes
Listing platform
You set price
You arrange
Yes
Listing + dealer offers
Instant (dealer) or listing
You arrange
Yes
Selling a Car with High Oil Consumption: What Each Buyer Offered
We submitted 5 oil-burning vehicles to Peddle, CashForCars, and Wheelzy using the same Florida zip code. Here’s what each buyer offered.
All Offers at a Glance
Vehicle
2004 Nissan 350Z
$2,805
$1,267
$440
2009 Pontiac Vibe
$655
$450
Required call
2008 Toyota Yaris
$560
$506
Required call
2008 Ford Edge
$430
$450
$462
2005 Ford Mustang
$435
$450
$462
2004 350Z
2009 Vibe
2008 Yaris
2008 Edge
2005 Mustang
2004 Nissan 350Z Coupe
72,000 miles · burns oil
$2,805
$1,267
$440
2009 Pontiac Vibe Base
170,896 miles · burns oil
$655
$450
Required call
2008 Toyota Yaris Hatchback
380,000 miles · burns oil
$560
$506
Required call
2008 Ford Edge SEL
226,000 miles · burns oil
$462
$450
$430
2005 Ford Mustang Convertible
154,203 miles · burns oil
$462
$450
$435
Keep in mind: We got these quotes using a Florida zip code. Offers can change depending on where you live, your car’s condition, and what buyers need in your area. You might get higher or lower offers.
What This Tells Us
What this tells us:
The price gap between Peddle and Wheelzy grew much wider on vehicles with stronger resale appeal. On everyday commuter cars like the Edge and Mustang, all three buyers landed close together. On the 350Z, the spread was massive.
Wheelzy routed 2 out of 5 vehicles to a phone call rather than showing an instant quote. Both were the cars with the most extreme mileage in the test, which points to Wheelzy needing more information before pricing cars that have clearly passed typical operating life.
Peddle was stronger on vehicles where the engine still has usable value or the model has collector interest. Their pricing appears to factor in what the car was before the oil issue, not just what it costs to haul away.
CashForCars and Wheelzy both priced the lower-value cars in a narrow band that was very close to each other. That likely reflects a floor price for cars in this condition rather than a precise valuation.
CarBrain’s counteroffer option is worth using once you have quotes from Peddle, CashForCars, and Wheelzy in hand. Showing a higher number to CarBrain gives you a real negotiating position that the other three services don’t offer.
eBay Motors and Facebook Marketplace could beat every instant buyer on price, but you need to be fully transparent about the oil issue in your listing. Buyers who find out at inspection tend to walk away or make much lower offers.
Getting quotes from Peddle, CashForCars, and Wheelzy takes about 5 to 10 minutes total. In our test, the difference between the highest and lowest offer on the same car was larger than most sellers would expect.
See how offers compare for your specific car before you decide which buyer to use.
Which company is best for selling a car with high oil consumption?
Peddle offered the most on 3 of the 5 vehicles we tested, making them the most consistent option for oil-burning cars. Wheelzy beat both competitors on the Mustang and Edge, so checking all three gives you the best chance of finding the highest offer.
How much can I get for a car that burns oil?
It depends heavily on the car’s make, model, mileage, and whether it still runs. In our test, offers ranged from $430 for an older high-mileage SUV to $2,805 for a sports car with lower mileage. Oil consumption on its own doesn’t kill the value as much as the car’s overall condition and what buyers in your area need.
Should I fix the oil consumption problem before selling?
It depends on the cost to fix it versus how much more you’d get. Minor fixes like replacing piston rings can cost $1,000 to $4,000 or more. If the instant buyer quotes are already close to what you’d get after fixing it, selling as-is usually makes more financial sense.
Getting a repair estimate first helps you make that math work. You can use RepairPal to get a fair estimate before deciding whether to fix or sell.
Yes. Peddle buys cars with any type of mechanical issue, including engines that burn oil. Their website mentions buying cars that won’t start, have blown engines, or have failed transmissions. High oil consumption falls within that range. They’ll ask about the car’s running condition and any known issues when you fill out the quote form.
Does Wheelzy buy cars with high oil consumption?
Yes. Wheelzy specifically mentions buying cars with broken engines and engine damage. A car burning oil qualifies as long as the engine and transmission are still present. In our test, they gave instant quotes on 3 out of 5 oil-burning cars and required a phone call for the other two.
Does CashForCars buy cars with high oil consumption?
Yes. CashForCars states on their website that they buy vehicles with mechanical problems and that all vehicles with or without problems have value. They gave instant online quotes for all 5 oil-burning vehicles in our test.
Does CarBrain buy cars that burn oil?
Yes. CarBrain buys cars with major engine problems, which includes high oil consumption. Their form asks about the car’s condition and any known mechanical issues. Unlike the other instant buyers, CarBrain lets you counter their first offer if you have a higher quote from a competitor.
What should I tell buyers about my car’s oil consumption?
Be specific. Mention how often you need to add oil (for example, every 500 miles or every 1,000 miles) and whether the car smokes at startup or under acceleration. Instant buyers like Peddle and Wheelzy price these cars based on your description.
Can I sell a car with high oil consumption on Facebook Marketplace?
Yes, and you may get more money than an instant buyer offers. The key is disclosing the issue clearly in your listing.
Buyers who know about it upfront are more likely to follow through. Mechanics, hobbyists, and project car buyers on Facebook Marketplace often look specifically for cars with known fixable issues.
Will high oil consumption stop a car from passing inspection at pickup?
Instant buyers like Peddle, CashForCars, and Wheelzy buy cars as-is. There is no inspection requirement for you to pass before they pick up the car. The driver does check that the car matches what you described. If you disclosed the oil issue accurately, the offer should stay the same at pickup.
We selected 5 vehicles that all had high oil consumption as their primary issue: a 2004 Nissan 350Z Coupe (72,000 miles), a 2005 Ford Mustang Convertible (154,203 miles), a 2008 Ford Edge SEL (226,000 miles), a 2008 Toyota Yaris Hatchback (380,000 miles), and a 2009 Pontiac Vibe Base (170,896 miles).
We submitted each vehicle to Peddle, CashForCars, and Wheelzy using the same Florida zip code. We answered all questions honestly, disclosed the oil consumption issue on each form, and took screenshots of every result. We did not accept any offers.
Your results may differ based on location, your car’s specific condition, and which buyers are active in your area at the time you request a quote.
offered the most on 3 out of 5 vehicles, including $2,805 for the 2004 Nissan 350Z, which was $1,538 more than the next highest offer on that car
beat both
on the 2005 Ford Mustang and 2008 Ford Edge, but required a phone call for 2 out of 5 vehicles
lets you counter their first offer if you think your car is worth more, which no other instant buyer on this list allows
