I want to take the guesswork out of selling your car. I analyze market data, decode DMV title laws, and test out online car buyers to give you a straight answer on whether it's worth holding out for a higher price or if you're better off taking the most convenient offer and moving on.
Published:May 31, 2025
Last Updated:Apr 21, 2026
✓ Fact Checked
How is this page verified?
Information on this article is compiled from publicly available data, customer feedback and our internal analysis. All our articles are being constantly updated and fact-checked annually to ensure accuracy, timeliness, and relevance.
The bottom line: If you’re choosing between CarGurus and Cars.com, CarGurus is the better choice for a newer truck or SUV. It offered more in our tests whenever it made an offer, and its offers last longer.
Its instant offer can come with free home pickup. Not every car qualifies, though, and older cars and EVs can get turned down.
Cars.com is the better fit if you want to sell privately for more money, or if CarGurus rejects your car. Its dealer offers mean a trip to the dealer.
Neither is the right buyer for a junk car, a salvage title or a car with major damage. Quotes from both cost nothing, so get both before you accept one.
Key Takeaways
How we tested: We had both companies quote the same three clean-title cars in January 2026, and three more cars in 2025.
Trucks and SUVs: CarGurus offered more for both the truck and the SUV, with its biggest lead on a 2022 Ford F-150 XL, $24,500 against $16,450.
When CarGurus says no: Cars.com offered $12,925 for a 2018 Tesla Model 3 that CarGurus made no offer on, and it also lets you list privately for free.
Expert AdvisorAsk me anything about selling your car
Try asking
Automated assistant: general info, not legal advice
Answers come from our state paperwork data and published guides. Confirm anything binding with your state DMV.
CarGurus vs Cars.com at a Glance
Category
Best For
Newer trucks and SUVs, potential home pickup
Private sales, maximum money
Quote Speed
About 2 minutes
A few minutes
Offer Validity
7 days or 250 miles
3 business days
Private Sales
Not available (ended June 2024)
Free listings, no expiration
Pickup Service
Free home pickup for instant offers (depends on car and location)
Must visit dealer
Payment Method
Bank transfer (1 to 3 days) or check
Check from dealer same day
Cars with Loans
Handles loan payoff for instant offers
Dealer handles payoff
Quote Reliability
Instant offers more reliable; dealer quotes are recommendations only
Dealers may adjust after inspection
Won’t Buy
Older cars, salvage titles, high mileage EVs, major damage
Cars under $1,000 or older than 17 years (for instant offers)
Trustpilot Rating
3.3/5 stars (1,191 reviews)
2.1/5 stars (83 reviews)
Google Rating
2.8/5 stars (108 reviews)
4.1/5 stars (19 reviews)
BBB Status
A+ rating
A+ rating
Main Drawback
Many cars get no offers; dealer quotes can change at inspection
Dealers often lower price after inspection, spam messages on private listings
CarGurus vs. Cars.com Offers
We requested quotes from both companies for several vehicles. Here’s what each one offered:
2026
2025
Vehicle
Winner
2022 Ford F-150 XL
$24,500
$16,450
CarGurus +$8,050
2021 Toyota RAV4 Prime SE
$25,700
$24,125
CarGurus +$1,575
2018 Tesla Model 3
No offers
$12,925
Cars.com
2022 Ford F-150 XL with 72.5k miles and clean title:
2022 Ford F-150 XL
CarGurus: $24,500
Cars.com: $16,450
2021 Toyota RAV4 Prime SE with 61.5k miles and clean title:
2021 Toyota RAV4 Prime SE
CarGurus: $25,700
Cars.com: $24,125
2018 Tesla Model 3 with 73k miles and clean title:
2018 Tesla Model 3
CarGurus: No offers
Cars.com: $12,925
Vehicle
Winner
2023 Ford F-150
$29,500 to $33,000
$32,695
CarGurus (up to +$305)
2022 Chevrolet Bolt
$14,100 to $15,600
$14,988
CarGurus (up to +$612)
2020 Jeep Grand Cherokee
$11,500 to $16,800
$14,200 to $16,800
Tie (same top offer)
2023 Ford F-150 with 37k miles and clean title:
CarGurus: $29,500 to $33,000
CarGurus dealer offers
Cars.com: $32,695
2022 Chevrolet Bolt with 36k miles and clean title:
CarGurus: $14,100 to $15,600
CarGurus dealer offers
Cars.com: $14,988
2020 Jeep Grand Cherokee with 103k miles:
2020 Jeep Grand Cherokee
CarGurus: $11,500 to $16,800
Cars.com: $14,200 to $16,800
CarGurus vs. Cars.com: Detailed Comparison
The biggest difference is how long offers last. CarGurus gives you 7 days or 250 additional miles to decide, while Cars.com offers expire in just 3 business days. If you have a busy schedule or need time to think, CarGurus is more flexible.
CarGurus offers two selling options: their instant offer with free home pickup, or connecting you with local dealers. Not all cars qualify for the instant offer. Depending on your vehicle and location, you may only get dealer quotes. These dealer quotes are recommendations, not guaranteed prices, and can change after the dealer inspects your car. Cars.com requires you to visit a dealer in person for their instant offers.
Our 2026 tests showed a clear pattern: CarGurus offered more money when vehicles qualified. The Ford F-150 got $8,050 more through CarGurus, and the Toyota RAV4 Prime got $1,575 more. But CarGurus rejected our Tesla Model 3 entirely while Cars.com offered $12,925.
Both services connect you with dealers who inspect your car. The key differences in how they work:
CarGurus instant offer: Driver comes to your home, quote is more likely to hold
CarGurus dealer quotes: Recommendations only, can change at the dealership
Cars.com: You drive to a participating dealer for in-person inspection
Cars.com has one major advantage: free private listings that reach about 25 million monthly visitors. Their Caramel partnership handles DMV paperwork and secure payment for free on cars worth over $1,000. Private sales typically bring 10% to 15% more money than dealer offers, but can take up to 8 weeks to complete.
If you’re looking for more options, check out other online car buyers who may offer competitive prices for your vehicle.
Alternatives to Sell a Car
4.6
Scored against used car buyers only
CategoryScore
Offer amount35%5/5
Process ease20%5/5
Offer validity15%4/5
Pickup / drop-off15%4/5
Payment speed15%4/5
Scores compare companies within one segment, never across. How we score
Want to compare more options? Use our free tool to see who offers the most for your car:
Compare Instant Offers
Compare Instant Offers
0/17
VIN cannot contain O, I, or Q
OR
Frequently Asked Questions
Which offers more money, CarGurus or Cars.com?
In our 2026 tests, CarGurus offered more when vehicles qualified. CarGurus offered $24,500 for a Ford F-150 compared to Cars.com’s $16,450 (a difference of $8,050).
For a Toyota RAV4 Prime, CarGurus offered $25,700 versus Cars.com’s $24,125 (a difference of $1,575).
However, CarGurus rejected our Tesla Model 3 with no offers while Cars.com offered $12,925.
Our 2025 tests showed CarGurus had the potential to offer more, with their top quotes matching or beating Cars.com on trucks and SUVs.
How long do CarGurus and Cars.com offers last?
CarGurus offers are valid for 7 days or 250 additional miles, whichever comes first. Cars.com instant offers expire after just 3 business days.
If you have a busy schedule, CarGurus gives you more than twice as much time to decide.
Which has better reviews, CarGurus or Cars.com?
CarGurus has 3.3 stars on Trustpilot from 1,191 reviews.
Cars.com has 2.1 stars from 83 reviews. Both have A+ ratings with the Better Business Bureau.
Common complaints about CarGurus include dealer quotes being reduced after inspection (since dealer quotes are only recommendations) and some vehicles getting no offers at all.
Cars.com complaints mention dealers lowering prices after inspection and spam messages when listing privately.
Do CarGurus or Cars.com change offers at pickup?
It depends on the type of offer. CarGurus instant offers with home pickup are more likely to hold because they’re locked in prices.
However, CarGurus dealer quotes are only recommendations based on dealer rating and inventory needs. These dealer quotes can change when you visit the dealership.
Cars.com sellers frequently report dealers lowering the price after the in-person inspection.
Be honest about your car’s condition when getting quotes. The more accurate your description, the less likely your offer will change.
Which is faster, CarGurus or Cars.com?
CarGurus can be faster if you qualify for their instant offer with home pickup.
You can complete the sale without visiting a dealership. If you only get dealer quotes from CarGurus, you’ll need to visit a dealership similar to Cars.com.
For private sales, Cars.com listings can take up to 8 weeks to find a buyer. CarGurus no longer offers private sales as of June 2024.
How do CarGurus and Cars.com pay you?
CarGurus offers bank transfers that arrive in 1 to 3 business days for instant offer sales, or a check at pickup. Dealer sales through CarGurus pay the same day you complete the sale at the dealership.
Cars.com dealer offers pay with a check the same day you complete the inspection. For private sales through their Caramel partnership, payment is held in escrow until the sale completes.
Can I sell a financed car to CarGurus or Cars.com?
Yes, both services accept cars with loans. CarGurus handles the loan payoff directly for their instant offer sales.
They send you the difference if your offer is more than what you owe. If you owe more than the offer, you need to pay the gap.
Cars.com dealers handle loan payoffs their own way. You’ll work out the details during your visit.
Can I list my car privately on CarGurus?
No, CarGurus ended private party sales in June 2024. They now only offer dealer purchases and instant offers (where available).
If you want to sell your car privately, Cars.com offers free listings with no expiration date that reach about 25 million monthly visitors.
Does CarGurus always offer home pickup?
No, home pickup is only available for CarGurus instant offers, and not all vehicles qualify. Depending on your car type and location, you may only receive dealer quotes instead.
Dealer quotes require you to visit a dealership in person, similar to Cars.com’s process.
Are CarGurus and Cars.com legitimate?
Yes, both are legitimate companies. CarGurus has been around since 2006 and is publicly traded on Nasdaq.
Cars.com has been operating since 1998 and is also publicly traded on the NYSE. Both have A+ ratings with the Better Business Bureau.
Article Update History
Updated
New quotes from both, ratings from Trustpilot and Google, and BBB status confirmed.
