SellCarAdvisor is reader-supported, when you sign up through links on this post, we may receive compensation at no extra cost to you. How We Work.
The bottom line: Cars & Bids is built for modern enthusiast vehicles, with zero seller fees and a community of serious car lovers. But it rejects about 60% of submissions, and if your car doesn’t sell, you wait a full year before trying again.
Bring A Trailer sold over 40,000 vehicles in 2025 for $1.7 billion total, making it the biggest enthusiast auction platform by far. Hemmings gives classic car collectors three ways to sell with automatic backup listings if auctions don’t hit reserve. eBay Motors opens your car to 11 million monthly shoppers with flat listing fees starting at $19.
Each platform attracts a different type of buyer. Bring A Trailer draws collectors willing to pay top dollar for well-documented cars. Hemmings reaches traditional classic car fans through both online listings and print. eBay Motors covers the widest range of vehicles without any selectivity.
The right choice depends on your car type, how fast you want to sell, and how much work you’re willing to do yourself.
Compare offers from multiple services with Sell Car Advisor to find who pays the most for yours.
Compare Instant Offers
Best Sites Like Cars & Bids
1. Bring A Trailer (Best for Rare and Collector Vehicles)
Bring A Trailer is the largest enthusiast car auction site, with over 700,000 registered users and $1.7 billion in total sales during 2025 alone. Sellers pay $99 for Classic listings or $429 for Plus (which includes professional photography), while buyers pay a 5% fee.
Every auction runs exactly seven days with an active comment section where buyers ask detailed questions. The 2-minute extension rule stops last-second bid sniping, and well-prepared sellers can now get listings live within a few days. White Glove service handles everything for high-end collections.
The approval process is strict, and BaT strongly pushes sellers toward no-reserve auctions. If you refuse to complete a sale after your auction ends, you get banned for life. Their payment partner Caramel has caused delays for some sellers trying to get funds.
Similarities with Cars & Bids
- Seven-day auction format with active comment sections where buyers vet listings and ask detailed questions about condition and history
- Professional listing support with auction specialists helping create detailed vehicle descriptions from seller-provided information
- Enthusiast-focused audience of serious buyers who understand vehicle values and appreciate unique specs and documentation
Differences from Cars & Bids
- Strong pressure for no-reserve auctions versus Cars & Bids allowing reasonable reserve prices for seller protection
- Lifetime ban if sellers refuse to complete a sale, compared to Cars & Bids’ less severe approach to transaction issues
- Broader vehicle categories including motorcycles, boats, ATVs, and memorabilia, while Cars & Bids focuses only on cars and trucks
- Much larger audience with 700,000+ registered users and $1.7 billion in 2025 sales versus Cars & Bids’ smaller but growing community
2. Hemmings (Best for Classic Car Collectors)
Hemmings has been connecting classic car collectors since 1954, with three selling options: Auction ($99.95), Make Offer ($99.95), and Classified Ad ($129.95 to $189.95). The platform draws over 400,000 monthly visitors who are serious about vintage vehicles.
Auction listings get a professional writer to create your description, and a free CARFAX report is included. If your auction doesn’t hit reserve, it automatically converts to a free 6-month Make Offer listing, with about 60% of those cars eventually selling during the extended period.
Hemmings steps back after connecting you with a buyer. You handle payment, title transfer, and shipping on your own. About 15% of initial sales fall through because buyers back out, and Hemmings provides limited help with disputes.
Similarities with Cars & Bids
- Professional listing support with dedicated specialists helping create detailed vehicle descriptions and presentations
- Targeted enthusiast audience of serious collectors who understand classic car values and appreciate thorough documentation
- Buyers pay a 5% fee on top of the sale price, keeping the main transaction amount in the seller’s pocket
Differences from Cars & Bids
- Traditional classic car focus (primarily pre-1980s) versus Cars & Bids’ modern enthusiast vehicles from the 1980s to today
- Three selling formats (Auction, Make Offer, Classified Ad) versus Cars & Bids’ single auction approach
- Print magazine exposure through Hemmings Motor News, which Cars & Bids doesn’t offer
- Automatic backup listing if auction doesn’t sell, versus Cars & Bids’ 365-day waiting period before relisting
3. eBay Motors (Best for Maximum Exposure)
eBay Motors reaches about 11 million monthly car shoppers and claims a car sells every 60 seconds. You pay a flat listing fee of $19 (Basic), $49 (Plus), or $79 (Premium) with no percentage taken from your sale price.
The platform accepts virtually any vehicle type without approval requirements. You can choose between auction or fixed-price formats, with up to 40 photos allowed on Premium listings. An AutoCheck vehicle history report is included, and the Second Chance Offer feature lets you contact the next-highest bidder if the winner backs out.
You do everything yourself: photos, description, buyer questions, and shipping arrangements. Winning bids aren’t legally binding, so buyers can walk away. There’s also a 2.8% fee on deposits when buyers pay through eBay’s system.
Similarities with Cars & Bids
- No percentage commission on the final sale price, with both platforms using flat or fixed fee structures for sellers
- Nationwide buyer reach connecting sellers with buyers across the country rather than limiting to local markets
- Reserve price option available on auctions, letting sellers set a minimum selling price for protection
Differences from Cars & Bids
- No vehicle selectivity, accepting any car type, versus Cars & Bids’ 60% rejection rate for non-enthusiast vehicles
- Non-binding auction results allow buyers to legally back out versus Cars & Bids’ more committed bidding community
- Completely self-managed process for photos, descriptions, and buyer communication versus Cars & Bids’ hands-on listing support
- Immediate listing approval versus Cars & Bids’ 2 to 3 week submission-to-auction timeline
Compare in detail: Cars & Bids vs eBay Motors Comparison
You can compare instant cash offers across multiple services using our comparison tool:
Compare Instant Offers
Compare Instant Offers
Why Look for Alternatives to Cars & Bids?
Potential Drawbacks of Cars & Bids
High Rejection Rate: Cars & Bids rejects about 60% of submissions because they only want enthusiast vehicles. If your car is a regular daily driver without special features or modifications, you’ll likely need to look elsewhere.
365-Day Relisting Wait: If your vehicle doesn’t sell or doesn’t meet your reserve, you have to wait a full year before listing the same car again. This ties your hands if market conditions change or you need to sell sooner.
Non-Paying Buyers: While Cars & Bids checks buyer creditworthiness, winning bidders can back out without real financial penalties. Some sellers on review sites mention this as a frustrating part of the process.
Long Timeline to Go Live: The process from submission to live auction can take 2 to 3 weeks. If you need to sell your car quickly, this timeline may not work for your situation.
Benefits of Shopping Around
Different Audiences for Different Cars: Bring A Trailer’s 700,000+ registered users skew toward high-end collectors, Hemmings reaches traditional classic car fans, and eBay Motors covers mainstream buyers. Matching your car to the right audience can make a big difference in your final price.
More Flexible Selling Options: Hemmings gives you three listing types with automatic backup if auctions fail. eBay Motors lets you list immediately with fixed-price or auction formats. Cars & Bids only offers one approach with strict timelines.
Lower Risk If Your First Choice Fails: Having backup platforms ready helps when Cars & Bids rejects your submission, your auction doesn’t meet reserve, or the winning bidder backs out. You won’t have to wait a year to try again somewhere else.
Different Fee Structures: eBay Motors charges flat fees starting at $19 with no sale percentage. Hemmings offers $99.95 listings with free backup periods. Bring A Trailer starts at $99 with professional listing support. Each structure may work better depending on your car’s value.
Learn more: Best Online Car Auction for Private Sellers With No Fees
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes Cars & Bids different from Bring A Trailer, Hemmings, and eBay Motors?
Cars & Bids focuses on modern enthusiast vehicles from the 1980s to today, with zero seller fees and professional listing support from their team. The platform has a smaller, more targeted community compared to Bring A Trailer’s 700,000+ users.
Bring A Trailer covers a wider range of collector vehicles and memorabilia. Hemmings specializes in traditional classic cars. eBay Motors accepts any vehicle without selectivity.
Which Cars & Bids alternative gets the highest sale prices?
Bring A Trailer typically achieves the highest prices for rare, well-documented vehicles. Their expert community and global reach create strong bidding competition, and their top sale in 2025 was a Ferrari LaFerrari at $4.475 million.
For traditional American classics, Hemmings can match or beat other platforms because their audience specifically looks for those vehicles. eBay Motors’ massive audience can drive competitive pricing for the right car, though results vary more widely.
How long does it take to list on each Cars & Bids alternative?
eBay Motors is the fastest. You can create a listing in about an hour and go live immediately. Bring A Trailer approval can happen within a few days for well-prepared submissions, though complex listings may take longer.
Hemmings auction listings can take 2+ weeks to go live after submission. Cars & Bids typically takes 2 to 3 weeks from submission to live auction.
Which platform works best for first-time car sellers?
eBay Motors is the most beginner-friendly option. There’s no approval process, listing is straightforward, and you have full control over pricing and timing. The Second Chance Offer feature helps if your first buyer falls through.
Cars & Bids offers the most hands-on support if your vehicle gets approved. Bring A Trailer and Hemmings expect more experience with detailed vehicle documentation and active community engagement during auctions.
What happens if a car doesn’t sell on these platforms?
Hemmings automatically converts failed auctions to a free 6-month Make Offer listing at no extra cost. About 60% of cars that don’t sell at auction eventually sell during this extended period.
Bring A Trailer runs a structured 24-hour negotiation window between the highest bidder and seller. eBay Motors lets you relist at no extra cost if the first listing doesn’t work. Cars & Bids makes you wait 365 days before trying again.
Do any Cars & Bids alternatives help with shipping?
None of these platforms handle shipping directly. Bring A Trailer offers a shipping service with instant quotes on listings, but it focuses mainly on domestic transport. eBay Motors and Hemmings can recommend shipping companies.
On all platforms, you’ll work out pickup or delivery details directly with the buyer after the sale.
Learn more: Best Places to Sell a Car for Free
What fees does each platform charge sellers?
Cars & Bids charges sellers nothing to list or sell. Bring A Trailer charges $99 (Classic) or $429 (Plus). Hemmings charges $99.95 for auctions or Make Offer listings, and $129.95 to $189.95 for classified ads. eBay Motors charges $19 to $79 per listing.
On all four platforms, buyers pay a separate fee. Bring A Trailer and Hemmings both charge buyers 5%. eBay Motors charges a 2.8% deposit processing fee. Cars & Bids charges buyers a 5% fee with a $250 minimum and $7,500 cap.
Article Update History
Similarities and differences were reviewed against current company policies, fee structures, and features. Bring A Trailer's 2025 annual sales data was confirmed through their official year-end report.
Originally posted and shared with our readers.