SellCarAdvisor is reader-supported, when you sign up through links on this post, we may receive compensation at no extra cost to you. How We Work.
The bottom line: Bring A Trailer is the biggest online auction platform for enthusiast and collector cars, selling over 40,000 vehicles worth $1.7 billion in 2025. But its slow approval process, reserve price pressure, and $99 to $429 listing fees push many sellers to look elsewhere.
We compared five alternatives that offer different advantages. Cars & Bids charges sellers nothing to list and responds to submissions within one business day. eBay Motors reaches 11 million monthly shoppers and lets you list without any approval process for $19 to $79.
Hemmings gives classic car sellers three listing formats and converts unsold auctions into free 6 month Make Offer listings. Autotrader provides built in buyer verification and secure payments. Facebook Marketplace is completely free and puts your car in front of millions of local buyers instantly.
Each platform works better for different sellers. The right choice depends on your car type, how fast you need to sell, and how much work you want to do yourself.
Compare offers from multiple services with Sell Car Advisor to find who pays the most for yours.
Compare Instant Offers
Best Sites Like Bring A Trailer
1. Cars & Bids (Best for Zero Seller Fees)
Cars & Bids was founded by popular car reviewer Doug DeMuro and focuses on modern enthusiast cars from the late 1970s to today. Sellers pay nothing to list and keep 100% of the sale price. Buyers pay a 5% fee with a $250 minimum and $7,500 cap.
The platform accepts about 40% of submissions, which is selective but less restrictive than BaT. Their team helps write your listing, and auctions go live as soon as one week after approval. More than 80% of cars that go to auction actually sell.
The one per year listing rule is a drawback. If your car doesn’t sell, you have to wait a full year before trying again on Cars & Bids. Customer support can also take 24 to 48 hours to respond.
Similarities with Bring A Trailer
- Both run 7 day auctions with active comment sections where buyers ask questions and compete
- Both focus on enthusiast vehicles and attract serious car buyers who understand values
- Both require detailed photos and documentation for every listing
Differences from Bring A Trailer
- Sellers list for free on Cars & Bids versus $99 to $429 on Bring A Trailer
- Approval takes about one business day versus 1 to 3 weeks on BaT
- Focuses on modern enthusiast cars (1980s to today) while BaT covers all eras including pre-war classics
- SafePay secure payment costs $99 versus BaT’s Verified Checkout which is free but mandatory if the buyer picks it
2. eBay Motors (Best for Maximum Exposure)
eBay Motors gets about 11 million car shoppers every month, and a car sells every 60 seconds on the platform. You pay a flat fee of $19 to $79 to list, with no percentage taken from your final sale price.
There’s no approval process. You can list any vehicle right away and choose between auction style or fixed price format. The Premium package ($79) gives you up to 40 photos and an AutoCheck vehicle history report. Their Second Chance Offer feature lets you contact the next highest bidder if your winner backs out.
You do everything yourself on eBay Motors. That means writing the listing, answering questions, arranging shipping, and handling title transfer. Winning bids aren’t legally binding, so buyers can back out without real consequences.
Similarities with Bring A Trailer
- Both offer auction formats with detailed vehicle listings and photo requirements
- Both attract enthusiast buyers looking for unique or collector vehicles
- Both support 7 day auction timelines as a standard option
Differences from Bring A Trailer
- No listing approval process versus BaT’s selective curation that can take 1 to 3 weeks
- Flat listing fees ($19 to $79) with no percentage of sale versus BaT’s $99 to $429 listing fees plus 5% buyer premium
- Accepts any vehicle type while BaT only lists cars with enthusiast appeal
- Offers Buy It Now and Make Offer options alongside auctions versus BaT’s auction only format
3. Hemmings (Best for Classic Car Collectors)
Hemmings has been serving classic car enthusiasts since 1954 and reaches over 400,000 collectors every month. You can sell three ways: Auction ($99.95), Make Offer ($99.95), or Classified Ad ($129.95 to $189.95).
Their auction listings get a professional writer to create your car’s description, and a free CARFAX report is included. If your auction doesn’t hit the reserve, it automatically converts into a free 6 month Make Offer listing. About 60% of cars that don’t sell at auction end up selling during this period.
Hemmings connects you with buyers but steps back after that. You handle payment, title transfer, and shipping yourself. Auction listings can take 2 or more weeks to go live, and about 15% of initial sales fall through because buyers back out.
Similarities with Bring A Trailer
- Both focus on classic and collector vehicles with audiences of serious enthusiasts
- Both require detailed documentation and high quality photos for listings
- Both have professional staff who help write auction listings based on your materials
Differences from Bring A Trailer
- Three listing formats (Auction, Make Offer, Classified) versus BaT’s auction only approach
- Classified ads get you into the Hemmings Motor News print magazine for extra exposure
- Failed auctions automatically become free 6 month Make Offer listings versus BaT’s limited post auction support
- Buyers pay a 5% fee only on auction sales versus BaT’s 5% fee on all transactions
4. Autotrader (Best for Safe Private Sales)
Autotrader runs a Private Seller Exchange that focuses on security. Every buyer must verify their identity, payments go through Autotrader’s system, and they help with title paperwork. Your listing shows up on both Autotrader and Kelley Blue Book for double the exposure.
Listing costs $9 for cars under $10,000 or $49 for cars worth more. When your car sells, Autotrader takes 0.99% of the sale price with a $99 minimum. You also get a free AutoCheck vehicle history report and KBB pricing data to help set your price.
Cars made before 1990 can’t be sold through the Private Seller Exchange. This means classic car sellers need to look elsewhere. Some sellers also report getting messages from dealers even though the platform is meant for private sales.
Similarities with Bring A Trailer
- Both provide vehicle history reports to build buyer confidence
- Both have built in messaging systems to keep seller contact info private
- Both reach a nationwide audience of car shoppers beyond your local area
Differences from Bring A Trailer
- Fixed price format with buyer negotiations versus BaT’s auction only model
- Built in buyer identity verification and secure payments versus BaT where buyers and sellers handle transactions mostly on their own
- No approval process for listings versus BaT’s 1 to 3 week review period
- Excludes pre-1990 vehicles while BaT specializes in classic and vintage cars
5. Facebook Marketplace (Best for Free Local Listings)
Facebook Marketplace lets you list your car for free and reach millions of local buyers instantly. There are no listing fees, no commissions, and no approval process. Your listing goes live the moment you hit publish.
Cars priced under $10,000 sell the fastest. You can also post your listing in local car groups for extra exposure. Facebook suggests a price range based on similar cars in your area, and the messaging system lets you talk to buyers without giving out your phone number.
You handle everything yourself, including photos, test drives, payment, and paperwork. Expect 30 to 40 messages per listing, but only one or two serious buyers. Facebook doesn’t protect you if something goes wrong with payment.
Similarities with Bring A Trailer
- Both let you sell directly to individual buyers rather than to dealers
- Both use built in messaging so your personal contact info stays private
- Both require good photos to attract serious buyers
Differences from Bring A Trailer
- Completely free with no fees of any kind versus BaT’s listing fees and 5% buyer premium
- Local buyer focused while BaT reaches a national and international enthusiast audience
- No curation or vehicle requirements versus BaT’s selective approval for enthusiast cars only
- Fixed price negotiation format versus BaT’s 7 day competitive auction
You can compare instant cash offers across multiple services using our comparison tool:
Compare Instant Offers
Compare Instant Offers
Why Look for Alternatives to Bring A Trailer?
Potential Drawbacks of Bring A Trailer
Reserve price pressure: BaT strongly encourages no reserve auctions and may suggest reserves lower than documented market values. Some sellers on ConsumerAffairs mention feeling pushed to accept terms they weren’t comfortable with. If your reserve is too high for their liking, they may reject your listing.
Non-paying buyers: Winning bidders sometimes don’t follow through with payment, and BaT offers limited help when this happens. They can connect you with the second highest bidder, but there’s no guarantee you’ll get paid. Reviews on Trustpilot mention this as an ongoing concern.
Slow approval process: Getting your car listed can take 1 to 3 weeks or longer. BaT reviews every submission and frequently rejects vehicles they don’t consider interesting enough. Cars & Bids and eBay Motors both get you listed much faster.
Limited dispute support: If something goes wrong after the sale, you’re mostly on your own to work it out with the buyer. BaT offers basic help but doesn’t step in to resolve disputes. Their payment partner Caramel has caused delays for some sellers trying to get paid.
Lifetime ban risk: If you refuse to sell your car after the auction ends, BaT bans you for life. This is a bigger commitment than other platforms where you can decline offers or relist freely.
Benefits of Shopping Around
Lower costs: Cars & Bids charges sellers nothing to list versus BaT’s $99 to $429 fees. eBay Motors charges a flat $19 to $79 with no percentage of your sale price. Facebook Marketplace is completely free.
Faster time to market: eBay Motors has no approval process at all. Cars & Bids responds within one business day. Autotrader and Facebook Marketplace let you list immediately. BaT’s 1 to 3 week wait means lost time and potential buyers.
More flexible selling formats: BaT only offers auctions. Alternatives give you options like fixed pricing, Make Offer, and classified listings. This lets you match the selling format to your situation instead of being locked into a 7 day auction.
Broader vehicle acceptance: eBay Motors and Facebook Marketplace accept any vehicle. Autotrader takes any car from 1990 or newer. If BaT rejects your submission, these platforms give you other ways to reach buyers.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much can I save on fees by using alternatives to Bring A Trailer?
Cars & Bids eliminates seller listing fees entirely, saving you $99 to $429 upfront. eBay Motors charges flat listing fees of $19 to $79 with no percentage of the sale price. Facebook Marketplace is 100% free.
On the buyer side, eBay Motors charges no buyer premium at all. Cars & Bids charges buyers 5% (same as BaT). Autotrader takes 0.99% from the seller with a $99 minimum, which is lower than BaT’s buyer fee structure on most sales.
Which Bring A Trailer alternative approves listings fastest?
Facebook Marketplace and eBay Motors have no approval process. You can list immediately. Autotrader also lets you post right away through their Private Seller Exchange.
Cars & Bids reviews submissions within one business day, and auctions can go live within a week. Hemmings takes about 2 weeks for auction listings. BaT typically takes 1 to 3 weeks or longer.
Which platform is best for selling a classic or collector car?
Hemmings is the strongest alternative for true classics and vintage vehicles. They’ve been in the classic car market since 1954 and reach over 400,000 collectors monthly. Their classified ads also get you into the Hemmings Motor News print magazine.
For modern enthusiast cars from the 1980s to today, Cars & Bids is the better fit. eBay Motors works for any era since they accept all vehicles.
Learn more: Best Places to Sell a Classic Car
Can I set reserve prices on these Bring A Trailer alternatives?
eBay Motors gives you complete control over reserve prices with no pressure. Cars & Bids allows reserves but encourages no reserve auctions because they attract more bids. Hemmings supports reserves across all listing formats.
Autotrader and Facebook Marketplace use fixed pricing, so you set exactly what you want and negotiate directly with buyers. No auction uncertainty at all.
What happens if my car doesn’t sell on these platforms?
Hemmings automatically converts failed auctions to free 6 month Make Offer listings. eBay Motors lets you relist for free. Facebook Marketplace listings stay active until you remove them.
Cars & Bids has a one per year limit, so you have to wait 12 months before listing the same car again. BaT offers a structured post auction offer process but generally doesn’t relist vehicles.
Which Bring A Trailer alternative has the largest audience?
eBay Motors has the biggest reach with 11 million monthly car shoppers. Facebook Marketplace reaches millions of local users. Autotrader gets dual exposure on both Autotrader and KBB.
BaT has over 700,000 registered users, and Cars & Bids has a growing community of over 500,000. Hemmings reaches 400,000+ classic car collectors. The best audience depends on whether you want broad reach or a focused enthusiast community.
Do I need to handle shipping myself on these platforms?
Yes, on most of these platforms you and the buyer work out shipping or pickup directly. BaT offers shipping quotes on some listings, and Cars & Bids can recommend shipping companies, but neither arranges transport for you.
Facebook Marketplace is local focused, so most sales involve the buyer picking up the car in person. If you’re selling a car privately, plan on handling the logistics yourself regardless of the platform.
Learn more: Best Places to Sell a Car for Free
Article Update History
Fee structures, listing timelines, and platform features were verified against current company websites and recent seller reviews.
Originally posted and shared with our readers.