The bottom line: CarGurus and CarMax both priced two of our latest test cars, and the dealer estimate CarGurus recommended beat CarMax’s offer by $6,100 for a 2022 Ford F-150 XL and by $3,300 for a 2021 Toyota RAV4 Prime. But the dealer can lower its estimate after seeing the car, or as the market moves, while CarMax changes its offer only if its store finds the car differs from what you entered.
CarGurus doesn’t buy cars directly, so both of its figures were dealers’ estimates, and you sell the car to the dealer you pick from those it shows you. CarMax makes its own offer and buys the car itself.
CarMax is interested in buying pretty much any car, so a car that gets no CarGurus estimate, such as an old or high-mileage one, can still get an offer at a CarMax store.
Before you drive to a CarGurus dealer, get CarMax’s offer and see what other buyers offer through Sell Car Advisor’s comparison form, so you have firm figures for the dealer’s final one to beat.
Key Takeaways
- What our tests found: For a 2022 Ford F-150 XL, a CarGurus dealer estimated $24,500 and CarMax offered $18,400, and for a 2021 Toyota RAV4 Prime, the dealer estimated $25,700 and CarMax offered $22,400.
- Still owe money on it: CarMax pays your lender after the sale, so keep up your payments until the lender shows the loan paid, and a CarGurus dealer guides you through settling the loan as part of its purchase.
- Watch out for: Plan to drive the car in, since a CarGurus sale has no pickup and CarMax’s home pickup isn’t offered everywhere and may cost a fee.
- Ratings: BBB grades CarGurus and CarMax A+; on Trustpilot, where most reviewers of both bought a car rather than sold one, CarGurus rates 3.3 from 1,191 reviews and CarMax 4.5 from 3,519, and CarGurus’ Google listing, reviewed by dealers as well as car buyers, rates 2.8 from 108.
- What CarGurus sellers report: Visit the CarGurus dealer while CarMax’s seven-day offer still stands, since some sellers were offered $1,500 to $6,000 below the estimate once the dealer saw the car.
- What CarMax sellers report: Make sure the trim and features you enter on CarMax’s form are the ones your car has, since the store checks both and some sellers had the offer cut when a trim or feature didn’t match.
- How you’re paid: CarMax pays by bank draft, a check its bank guarantees that has to be deposited, not cashed, while a CarGurus dealer pays by check or electronic transfer, on a timeline that varies by dealer.
- How fast you can sell: Each sale takes a single visit: CarMax buys at the store the same day, and a CarGurus dealer buys the car when you drop it off.
Compare Instant Offers
Where to Sell Your Car?
- Selling a truck or SUV in good conditionOffered $6,100 more for F-150 and $3,300 more for RAV4 in our tests
- Need your money within 1 to 3 daysCarGurus dealers can pay by electronic transfer, though each dealer’s payment timeline varies, versus 5 to 10 day check holds
- Want to compare multiple offers in one placeShows offers from several local dealers side by side
- Want to sell from home without visiting a storeAt-home pickup in most areas; CarGurus sales end at a dealer
- Selling an electric vehicleOffered $11,400 for Tesla Model 3 when CarGurus had no offers
- Prefer handling everything in personOver 250 stores with same-day check and free Lyft ride home
- Want to track your car’s value before sellingOffer Watch tool sends monthly value updates
Neither, if the car has a branded title, major damage, or very high mileage. CarGurus can turn these cars down, and CarMax refuses a salvage title and offers less for major damage. Try specialized junk car buyers instead.
CarGurus compares instant offers from local dealers side by side
- Offers compared side by side
- Star ratings for each dealer
- Handles your outstanding loans
- Dealer pays by check or transfer
-
Offer amount 35% 4/5
-
Process ease 20% 3/5
-
Offer validity 15% 3/5
-
Pickup / drop-off 15% 4/5
-
Payment speed 15% 4/5
CarMax inspects and buys your car at 250+ stores
- Buys your car even if you don't buy one there
- Offer holds seven days and is not negotiable
- At-home pickup, though not everywhere and a fee may apply
- Quote in about 2 minutes online
-
Offer amount 35% 3/5
-
Process ease 20% 3/5
-
Offer validity 15% 4/5
-
Pickup / drop-off 15% 4/5
-
Payment speed 15% 2/5
Automated assistant: general info, not legal advice
Answers come from our state paperwork data and published guides. Confirm anything binding with your state DMV.
CarGurus vs. CarMax: Detailed Comparison
| Category |
|
|
|---|---|---|
| Best For | Comparing several dealer offers at once | Newer cars when you want a same-day check |
| Quote Speed | About 2 minutes online | About 2 minutes online |
| Offer Validity | 7 days or 250 extra miles | 7 days from the day of the offer, online or in store |
| Time to Complete | One visit to the dealer you pick | 30 minutes (express) to 4 hours on busy days |
| Payment Method | Dealer pays by check or electronic transfer | Bank draft only, which you deposit at your bank |
| Pickup Fee | None offered; you take the car to the dealer | At-home pickup in most areas (fee may apply) |
| Inspection Type | Dealer inspection in person | Full 30 to 45 minute in-person inspection |
| Cars with Loans | Yes, through the dealer that buys the car | Yes, but some sellers waited 3 to 7 weeks for the payoff |
| Won’t Buy | Can turn down branded titles, high mileage, older cars, non-running cars | Salvage titles; a frame- or flood-damaged car gets a reduced offer |
| Trustpilot Rating | 3.3/5 stars (1,191 reviews) | 4.5/5 stars (3,519 reviews) |
| Google Rating | 2.8/5 stars (108 reviews) | Varies by location, usually 4+ stars |
| BBB Rating | A+ rating | A+ rating |
| Main Drawback | Dealer offers may differ from online estimate | Pays by bank draft, not bank transfer |
Note: CarGurus dealers have star ratings on the platform. CarMax service quality varies by location.
CarGurus vs. CarMax Offers
We requested quotes from both companies for several vehicles. Here’s what each one offered:
2018 Tesla Model 3 with 73k miles and clean title CarMax
See both offer screenshots
2022 Ford F-150 XL with 72.5k miles and clean title CarGurus +$6,100
See both offer screenshots
2021 Toyota RAV4 Prime SE with 61.5k miles and clean title CarGurus +$3,300
See both offer screenshots
How each offer can change
- CarGurus: you describe the car’s condition on the online form, and the dealer inspects it when you drop it off; the final offer can change from the online quote.
- CarMax: it runs a full 30 to 45 minute inspection at the store, and the final offer can change from the online quote.
Alternatives to Sell a Car
-
Offer amount 35% 5/5
-
Process ease 20% 5/5
-
Offer validity 15% 4/5
-
Pickup / drop-off 15% 4/5
-
Payment speed 15% 4/5
- Get a real offer in 2 minutes, with no listing
- No haggling: its best offer comes upfront
- Suits a car under 10 years old in good condition
- Pays off your loan when it buys the car
-
Offer amount 30% 5/5
-
Quote speed 20% 5/5
-
Pickup speed 20% 4/5
-
Vehicle acceptance 15% 5/5
-
Process ease 15% 5/5
- Buys any car in any condition, running or not
- An offer in seconds, with no listing to write
- Free towing, with no fees taken off the offer
- Pays by check on the spot at pickup
-
Offer amount 30% 4.5/5
-
Quote speed 20% 5/5
-
Pickup speed 20% 4/5
-
Vehicle acceptance 15% 4/5
-
Process ease 15% 2/5
- Owned by Copart, the salvage auction company
- Buys almost any vehicle with a motor, running or not
- Free towing, and it handles the title transfer
- Hands you a check at pickup, or mails it
To see what different buyers offer for your car, get quotes from several at once:
Compare instant offers before you accept one
Compare instant offers before you accept one
Frequently Asked Questions
Which offers more, CarGurus or CarMax?
In our January 2026 tests, CarGurus offered more for the Ford F-150 ($24,500 versus $18,400) and the RAV4 ($25,700 versus $22,400). That’s $6,100 and $3,300 more than CarMax.
But CarGurus doesn’t make offers for every car. The Tesla Model 3 got no offers from CarGurus, while CarMax offered $11,400. If your car is a truck or SUV in good shape, CarGurus will likely offer more.
For EVs or vehicles CarGurus rejects, CarMax may be your better option.
How long do CarGurus and CarMax quotes last?
Both offers last 7 days. CarGurus also has a 250-mile limit, so your offer expires if you drive more than 250 miles before accepting.
CarMax’s 7-day window starts when it makes the offer, online or in a store. You can use that time to get quotes from other buyers before deciding.
Which has better reviews, CarGurus or CarMax?
CarGurus has 2.8 stars on Google from 108 reviews, and 3.3 stars on Trustpilot from 1,191 reviews.
Sellers’ most common complaint is that the dealer offers less than the online figure.
CarMax has 4.5 stars on Trustpilot from 3,519 reviews. Google ratings vary by location, usually 4+ stars.
Sellers mention late loan payoffs and in-store offers that come in under the online quote.
Do CarGurus and CarMax change offers after inspection?
Both services may adjust the final offer based on inspection. CarGurus’ online quotes are estimates rather than locked-in prices. When dealers inspect your car in person, the offer may change.
CarMax runs a 30 to 45 minute inspection at the store. Reviewers on Trustpilot mention that in-store offers sometimes differ from the online quote.
Be honest about your car’s condition when getting quotes to keep surprises to a minimum.
Which is faster, CarGurus or CarMax?
It depends on what “faster” means to you. CarMax can complete the sale in one visit, sometimes in under 30 minutes with express drop-off.
But CarMax pays by bank draft, and your bank decides when the full amount is yours to use.
A CarGurus dealer can pay by electronic transfer, though each dealer’s payment timeline varies. If you need access to your funds quickly, CarGurus is the faster choice.
How do CarGurus and CarMax pay you?
Every CarGurus sale goes through a dealer, and the dealer pays you by check or electronic transfer. The timing depends on the dealer.
CarMax pays with a bank draft, a kind of check its issuing bank guarantees. You’ll need to deposit it at your bank, since it can’t be cashed.
What if I still owe money on my car?
Both companies buy financed cars. On CarGurus, the dealer that buys the car handles the payoff paperwork with your lender.
CarMax handles loan payoffs too, but some of its sellers’ lenders were paid only three to seven weeks after the sale. Keep making payments until the loan shows as paid off to protect your credit.
If you owe more than the offer, you’ll need to cover the difference yourself.
Article Update History
New test quotes, ratings from Trustpilot and Google, and CarMax's at-home pickup added.
Originally posted and shared with our readers.
